Click Here!

Reviews for Arithmantic Dating Agency

By : Shiv5468
  • From ANON - Pauline on March 17, 2004
    This story was such a joy to read. You are very gifted at humour, which is so tricky, and I love your characterisations and sub plots. Thanks so much. I think we really need an after wed wedding tale. Too good to stop here.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - deblovesdragon on March 17, 2004
    Lovely wedding Shiv. I really must have missed something a few chapters back, cause I don't realize when they got engaged. Oh well, me bad!

    Write the honeymoon soon please.

    Report Review

  • From ANON - Kat on March 17, 2004
    Great story, I just read it for the first time. Hope it's not over! Just wanted to note that Filch himself says he's a squib in the COS. Nevilles lack of ability in potions doesn't make him a borderline squib either... remember he excells in herbology. No mention is made of his skills in other classes, however, he does quite well in the D.A. which would indicate at least a normal level of magical talent. Not that I think any of it has any bearing on your fic. It's a great fic, Filch in Gryffindor or not! Thanks for a fun read!

    Report Review

  • From ANON - De..^<..^< . on March 17, 2004
    Chapter 20... THANK YOU for sharing this story with us!!! I have very much enjoyed every bit of it & am sorry to see it end!!! Maybe somewhere along the line you could grace us with a sequel*
    Report Review

  • From ANON - jeanette on March 17, 2004
    Shiv, I beg you, please write Minerva and Filch's wedding... I cannot wait to see how Severus would repay all of Minerva's kindness.. :)
    This was a great story.
    Jeanette
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Jenny on March 17, 2004
    Nice chapter.

    Can't for the life of me see that being a Squib is necessarily a discrete situation - for example, Neville, and indeed to some extent Hagrid.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Boudicca on March 17, 2004
    "Don't stun them, Filch!" shouted Umbridge angrily, for all the world as though it had been his suggestion.
    "Right you are, Headmistress!" wheezed Filch, who was a Squib and could no more have Stunned the fireworks than swallowed them. - from OotP, page 633, chapter 28 "Snape's Worst Memory"

    As for my comment about being a prick, I meant he, like Snape(who had good reason not to like Gryffindors) is a prick to all houses except Slytherin. Therefore not likely to be in Gryffindor weren't he a Squib.

    Just so you know, when I originally posted my comment to you it cut off the end of my message. What was at the end went a little like this: besides these minor overlooked details I think your story is great and can't wait to read more.

    I only realized the end was cut off today, my apies.ies.

    Report Review

  • From ANON - yncarn8 on March 17, 2004
    Aw. I do love a wedding. Great fic Shiv!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - ancientgirl on March 17, 2004
    Great chapter, but it the epilogue and we don't know where they went on their honeymoon. Are we getting more?
    Report Review

  • From ANON - mele on March 17, 2004
    thank you for the latest chapter! i have been waiting anxiously and patiently. ok, not so patiently. i want to play naughty professor! ooooo! what a line! oh! that could be a great title for a fanfic. i have no problem with filch being a griffindor. i just want to know about minerva and filch and how their date went. i know i'm a shameless smut monger...(hangs head in shame). but i'm an avid, eager smut monger! doesn't that count for something?
    so how does one play naughty professor? aloha, mele
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Jana on March 12, 2004
    Aaawwwwww! More please!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - friendlyquark on March 11, 2004
    Awwwww...... gods that was aweeet, honest and very true to character. Wow. What a great couple of chapters! I love your writing so very much! Sorry I haven't been reading and reviewing as much, my story ate my head for a couple days and I won't let myself read anything when I am blocked, too afraid I wiill sub-conciously steal something. :) But I loved his panic attack and Minerva's assessment of it and how Hermione responded. It was perfect.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Boudicca on March 09, 2004
    Squibs don't receive schooling at Hogwarts. They don't have any magical abilities. They are not sorted into houses. They do not have house colors. And, considering how much of a prick he is in the books, Filch sure as hell wouldn't be in Gryffindor.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Campy Capybara on March 08, 2004
    Oh Shiv, I love your tile/jigsaw theory of love - how simple yet profound you've made it all sound.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - spaz141 on March 08, 2004
    19 chapters of fun and wonderfulness. thanks.
    Report Review

T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!