Click Here!

Reviews for Snape\'s Choice

By : Witchcraft
  • From ANON - HMM on December 12, 2004
    After just reading through this chapter i noticed that this one part was exatly like another part in another story written by the author death... in that story snape and lucius are dueling over hermione, harry is his second coz ron is an ass and draco is lucius's 2nd..the only difference is that unforgivables werent allowed in the other one and it wasnt to the death...you might have read the story and inadvertantly added it in there because it is almost identical...ive read just about every story about hermione and snape and i remember them....i thought you should know...coz i dont think it was necessarily intentional
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Me on October 20, 2004
    I love your story. It is exciting!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - ally on September 12, 2004
    omg, plz never ever write again, kthnx.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Anon on September 12, 2004
    Sweet merciful Lord! This is one of the worst (and unintentionally funny) things I have ever read in my life. It's such a shame that valuable space on aff.net was wasted on this trash.

    And you mention you want to publish a book? That terrifies me.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - sushified on July 17, 2004
    Sometimes I read this story just for the laugh. Please go back to the hole where you crawled out of, before my thoracic cavity is covered in urine. Either you have trouble sorting out how to write properly, or you have an obvious concertion with leaving out character development all together. I suggest you sit down, find some other stories and here, and take notes. Please burn anything associated with this story, while I try to stop laughing and maybe bang my head against the wall to destroy any brain cells with this story in them.



    Report Review

  • From slygriff21 on March 16, 2004
    Great story! I loved the twist! I would have been angry if you would have killed off Severus. I love how you had at the end that good can't survive without evil and evilcouldn't survive without good. I can't wait to read your sequel.

    Tiffany
    Report Review

  • From WriterLady1031 on February 16, 2004
    I'm sorry, but I had to stop after reading the second chapter. The story line was very rushed and just not thought out on where it was supposed to go. I didn't even know or understand that Severus and Hermoine were married. There were no obionsions from her parents or from her friends, nothing from Dumbledore, and just none of Hermoine's own thoughts on the matter. That right there was just too strange for any story--it wasn't veelieelievable.

    Another problem was that you need to use proper puncuation in your story. Each time another person speaks, there needs to be a space between the lines to give a clear indication of who is speaking. You didn't have that in your story and it was very hard on the eyes.

    As a writer, it is your responisibilty to make sure that your work is in tip-top shape. What you've put out so far is not, yet you've kept on for another nineteen chapters. Just the fact that you've gotten enough bad reviews should tell you that you're not doing something right. Please go back and get somebody to read over your work for you. Find somebody who paid very good attention in English class, have them beta-read your story, and THEN put it back up here.

    I'm not telling you to not write, JUST DO A BETTER JOB. DON'T JUST TYPE SOMETHING AND PUT IT UP HERE AND EXPECT PEOPLE NOT TO COMPLAIN WHEN ITS GOT MISTAKES ALL OVER IT.

    I hate to yell, but you need to understand: Do a better job.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - shaz on February 10, 2004
    the idea is good but i think you could hav drawn it out more and gone into more detail, the ending was to quick and it felt a bit rushed but all in all it had a good plot, hope the sequel is posted soon
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Julie on February 08, 2004
    This was not very good. Your writing was ill-reviewed. You have so many grammaticrrorrrors that this paper looks like something a grade school child would write. Many times throughout the story you actually contradict your own plot. The language that the characters used was all wrong, as well as the personalities of the characters themselves. You said that you were working on a book to publish, that's great. Just remember to review your plot and grammer. Don't try to rush though things so much. The base of your story was great...if a little twisted. Just take you time and review your work.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - elvirasnape on February 08, 2004
    All I can say is "WHY????" Why did severus have to die?
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Missmagick on February 07, 2004
    um.. I'm not quite sure what to say to that. The story started out quite well and seemed to be somewhere, but then the last few chapters struck, leaving me quite dumbfounded and amazed and, i'm very sad to say , not in a good way. You seem to have completely lost interest in your own story and quite obviously wanted it over with and i'm sorry to say, but you have you wish, the story is now D.O.A. May it Rest in Peace. Please think and plan carefully before committing to further literary endeavers, otherwise you are just wasting your time and selling yourself short.
    Very sorry if this seems harsh at all but I really think you can do better if you try harder
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Anon on February 07, 2004
    No offense, but this last chapter you posted was kind of pathetic. The story was great and I really liked it but the ending was disappointing.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Snapeaholic on February 06, 2004
    This story started out really good, but it seems to have derailed quite rapidly in the last 2 chapters. It's really confusing and just strange. There has to have been some way you could have built up or alluded to this weird crap instead of just springing it. This story had a lot of potential. Sorry I couldn't be more positive, but the last 2 chapters have ruined a good thing.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - spaz141 on February 06, 2004
    This story started off really good, unfortunately it is going down fast. This is it for reviewing, if I can't say anything nice, I'd rather say nothing at all. Good luck to you.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Kate McGuire on January 30, 2004
    I caught this a few chapters back. I know you ment to have a comma in there but without it the first time I read it I nearly spit my coffee into my keyboard. You see I thought it said that they ate the owl that delivered the message.

    "That night as Severus and Hermione ate a owl came threw and dropped a letter on the table. He opened the letter and moaned."

    Talk about killing the messenger!

    Keep going I am enjoying the romp.
    Report Review

T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!