Click Here!

Reviews for The Kindest Curse

By : Quillusion
  • From maudlinmuggle on September 23, 2007
    Although this is long long after your request for feedback, I would love to read the rest of The Kindest Curse. It's so rare that I find a story that's so specially well thought out and witty. And, well, since the official series is now complete, you might consider posting whatever you had written. If you do feel uncomfortable going where Rowling has already written, I would just like to say that I for one have thorouhly enjoyed reading your work.
    Report Review

  • From kazfeist on July 06, 2007
    I always think a good story should be continued. I was a little confused, however, by the apparent jump between the events of Chapter 5 and those of Chapter 6. Hermione is cutting vegetables at Harry's, and then she's dancing with Draco at Dumbledore's. Just a bit choppy, I thought. Or, it could be that this is one of the stories that got mangled in the old AFF database fiasco?
    Report Review

  • From diamondnightskies on January 18, 2007
    Well, I can't remember the last date of update for this story, but I've just stumbled across it. For quite a while I was working way too much to delve into fanfiction since it has the tendency to suck up far too many hours at a given time. Anyway, I'm not sure if you've decided to continue this story or not, but I REALLY hope you are. I could care less if it mirrors Rowling's versions in any way. In fact I think the closer you got to her version, before her actually releasing it, the more of a wonderful surprise it would be - most especially for you. Personally I would love to have what I wanted to happen to occur (or thought SHOULD) actually do so. Imagine reading her book and thinking 'HA! I knew it!', and you have it in writing to boot. ;) I think your storyline is fantastic and love how you're handling Lucius. I'm a sucker always hoping for a happy ending. And I really want to know what you've done with Narcissa. PLEASE be continuing this story!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Kryxian on December 17, 2006
    Do please continue and, by all means, disregard HBP if needs be! I realise I am late encountering your fanfic, but it truly is one of the most intellectually stimulating, satisfying and well-written pieces I've read in quite some time - I would loathe for it to be discontinued. I've not read anything quite like it ever before. I was pleasantly surprised at your portrayal of Lucius; his character was realistically schismed.

    I thoroughly enjoyed the chapters already published and greatly anticipate more, if you choose to continue. I'll try to be patient. ;)
    Report Review

  • From ANON - kate on August 08, 2006
    I know I'm late to the party (as usual), but I would love to see you continue this. Pretty please?
    Report Review

  • From ANON - June W on June 21, 2006
    Update, please? (Ignore book6 if you need to!)
    Report Review

  • From ANON - chris on December 31, 2005
    nice, let me know when you have a new chapter or story, i love your work. if you ever need a beta or anything let me know, i'd love to help out.

    later,
    chris
    Report Review

  • From ANON - gill on November 04, 2005
    Sorry to nag (but 6 glasses of Baileys are making me more forthright than usual) -- it's been a few months now, and I'm sure I'm not the only person who's been checking regularly. This was/is a great fic, so I'd love for you to continue; have you made your mind up yet? Please put us out of our misery, one way or the other!
    gill
    Report Review

  • From ANON - vonHardenberg on October 30, 2005
    Must agree with most of the other reviewers, your writing is superior and while I await more of this story, I will read the other works in your folio. Bravo
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Alzadea on October 13, 2005
    Quillusion, please do continue with this story. Your Fic, Soul Searching, introduced me to the world of Harry Potter-- I read it before I ever read a single one of JK's books. I will be extremely depressed if you don't continue, because in my oppinion you are a very talented writer, and I have frequently lamented the fact that JK hasn't given some of out favorite character the kind of depth that you have.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - June on October 03, 2005
    Ch 7 note - go and finish the story, regardless of what HBP said. Perhaps add an author's note at the start of each chapter or the start of the story, saying "Written before HBP, not HBP compliant" or something like that. I too would appreciate more frequent updates, but real life comes first.....
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Allegra on September 28, 2005
    Oh my god yes, please please please continue. You know, as I was reading book 6, I DID think, "Clearly I have read too much fanfiction because this all sounds very familiar." However, I think it's bound to happen in a fandom this big, a thousand monkeys with their typewriters you know. Not that I have the money or would want to sift through every single story, but I'd bet any money that at least one person will write some element into their fanfic that will feature prominently in book 7 before we hear a hint of what's to come. I'm dying to see where you're going with this story and this pairing, and hopefully enough others do as well that you'll continue. I'll certainly be finding my way back here, no matter how long it takes between updates.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Shiv5468 on September 20, 2005
    Well I want to read it. Definitely.

    Absolutely.

    ~makes puppy dog eyes~
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Sea on September 15, 2005
    Marvelous story, I admire your style of writing. Please DO continue with it. Parallel or not, it is a fantastic work and deserves to be completed.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Anon on September 11, 2005
    I would like to provide my opinions per your request. First, there is nothing wrong with you continuing with your story. Quite honestly, while J.K. Rowling created the world of Harry Potter, she is not the greatest of writers. Heck, she is not even a good writer, though she has gotten thankfully better. However, she is ingenuous with her creativity and imagination. You on the other hand is by far a better writer stylistically and analytically. Secondly, your story may have similar plot undertones with book 6, but it is not so identical as to warrant claims of plagarism or nasty comments. Your focus is completely different than Rowling's and you do it much with more character analysis. I hope you do continue on with your story, and try to ignore people who try to put you down. They are obviously illiterate because they are prone to write in gibberish. I'm so glad there exists fanfiction writers who can write using correct grammar and original plots without resorting to the cliche, run-of-the-mill, sub-par bullshit that plague the fanfiction universe. Thank you from a reader who can actually read.

    Report Review

T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!