Click Here!

Reviews for The Hogwarts Challenge: Evolving Magic

By : kohaku
  • From ANON - JJ on June 01, 2005
    Now this is fun!!! Is Voldy controlling what's going wrong? Can't wait to see what else you have up your sleeve! Thanks.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Melagic on June 14, 2004
    I was very excited to see an update! It was O.K., it kind of seemed almost scattered, ao it was a little hard to follow at first, but interesting. I hope you'll go back to Harry and Draco soon too. And I definately will be reading until the end!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Iseult on June 14, 2004
    hi i am really enjoying this. I liked the ministry taskforce and cover up. Your use of Luna is more interesting than most other fan fic. And the most original kiss between HG/SS! Love it. Are you still needing a beta. My strengths are spelling, grammar, sentence construction and cannon fact. I like how people characterises HG/SS differently and put them into wonderful new worlds, so I am not big on plot and character criticisms unless there are inconsistencies between chapters.

    Report Review

  • From ANON - Melagic on June 02, 2004
    I'm a total regular reader and I'll read it until the end I promise. Especially if you stop driving me nuts with short chapters that keep leaving me hanging. AAAAAHHHH!! ;)
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Melagic on May 28, 2004
    Every time I see a new chapter I get all excited, but you keep leaving me hanging! AAAAHHHHH
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Romie on May 25, 2004
    Hehehe...I could just picture Harry and Ron's hands stuck in Harry's Hair. Yep...Ron would be a good Huff. Next chapter completely HG/SS....*cries*....I want my Draco.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Melagic on May 25, 2004
    You keep saying the action will hn inn in the next chapter, and I keep reading the next chapter, and it's never there!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Shin Tae on May 25, 2004
    YOu've got an interesting story here. I've read a lot of challenges so far, but nothing like this. I can sense action, mayem, and romance coming my way, and I intend to stay for the ride. I was wondering if you could post this story on LordandladySnape.net? I enjoy reading your story so far, but the print is just too small for me to handle anymore. And it seems you may have some script errors in all your chapters, at least it look like that with me. Please let me know what you think! I await for your reply. Cheers, Shin.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - SiLvEr on May 16, 2004
    NICE FICCY!! Keep up the good work! Please update soon

    Report Review

  • From ANON - kohaku on May 13, 2004
    And this is why, you should never publish when you're sleep deprived from finals. I hope my term papers made more sense than this chapter, disturbing thought. This is mostly from the students perspective so far, and they're still not clear what's going on, which is part of why everything is so vague. There will be a lot more explanation in the next few chapters, I promise to make everything more clear ^^'.

    Nerdgirl: Everyone is sorted into one of the teachers classes for the challenge. Which was one of the clues the sorting hat gave. So everyone is still in the same house as usual. The challenge can be solved differently, which class you're in determines how you're solving the challenge, and the students and teacher that you're teaming up with to solve the challenge. For example, Professor McGonagall will probably coach her students to approach and solve the challenge from a very Gryffindor perspective, but there could be students from Gryffindor, Hufflepuff, Ravenclaw, and Slytherin in her class. The sortinghat placed students under the teacher whose approach will emphasize their talents and abilities, so while it's likeley that you'll be sorted into the same class as your head of house, it's not guaranteed, as will become apparent on the first day of Challenge c ^_^ ^_^.

    Romie: thanks for the praise, I'm another slash fan myself. I'm so glad to hear that you like how I've written the characters, I've been trying to keep them unique and in character. Hopefully you'll like my Snape ^^'

    Xavier: You've got most of it right so far. Not just Draco, but the whole Slytherin house will be acting differently. This is, as was hinted at by the Dumbledore/McGonagall discussion, part of one of Voldemort's plans, and therefore S is is involved. The challenge is something the school itself has created, as a response to what has been happening in the magical world. Voldemort has a serious interest in making sure that it is his supporters who solve the challenge. The prize depends on who solves the challenge and how they solve it, while Voldemort didn't orchestrate it, he'll definitely take advantage of it. Voldemort's death was faked, but not by him. It was a ploy by the ministry to quell the rising hysteria about Voldemort's return. I'd meant to reveal lots of this more slowly throughout the story, but I guess my story just doesn't really make sense without it now. Rewrite time. Good luck on your finals too! Now I really can't wait for them to be over, I *need* to rewrite this.

    Sincere thanks to everyone who has read and reviewed so far, the feedback really helps!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Romie on May 13, 2004
    I loved Hermione's inspection of Harry where she is trying to see if he has suddenly become incredibly handsome. Heh...I picture Harry as attractive, but someone who would blend in with the crowd. It is his character, not his looks that make him special. Draco, on the other hand, I picture as someone who would always stand out in a crowd. They are just a wondeful fantasy couple....my OTP...and Draco is my fav in fanfiction. And this is a story I look forward to reading more of. The Dumbledore/Minerva interaction was funny....he can sure be annoying and I will always think of him when I see lemon drops. I want to know what is going on....five days till more. Really like your Hermione so far. Gotta admit that Snape really does not interest me as a romantic character (I really have an unfavorable impression of his appeal from the books), but as long as he's not with Harry or Draco, I can deal. As a matter of fact, I have read a few other WIP with the HG/SS pairing and it is actually growing on me....though I'll probably skim over the sex scenes with those two....I've become a slash obsessive. *laughs*....Did you say this was your first fic? Very nice! Please continue writing. I am enjoying!!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - NerdGirl on May 13, 2004
    Huh!?!....I am so confused....so were they sorted into new houses? Is Hermione now in Slytherin? please I am still fascianted with your story, but in the next chapter could you please do a "The Hogwarts Challenge: For Dummies" recap. I'm Lost.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - star on April 30, 2004
    please update sooner than a week!

    oh yea, I love this fic
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Snapeaholic on April 30, 2004
    Interesting start. I'm looking forward to seeing where this goes. Keep up the good work!
    Report Review

  • From Chickalupe on April 30, 2004
    Okay, this is my new favorite story. Mmm, ear nibbling. *shivers at the H/D hotness* Keep up the good work!! More please.
    ~Amber
    Report Review

T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!