Click Here!

Reviews for Meet The Grangers

By : Bluemidget57
  • From ANON - Blue on January 01, 2005
    Well, first I would like to thank all of you who have shown your distaste for the manner in which our dear (...) reviewer has been expressing their opinions about this story.

    I must confess I am at a loss to understand why he or she feels the need to be so upset about a piece of fiction about another piece of fiction. After her first review I asked for her to e mail me at my address up there and let us have a private discusion about the "insult" angle, (that would be 5 reviews now, I chose at first to delete her inane ramblings, but now I have no patience with them. Why not let everyone see what a missive idiot she is!) And since she has to make chosen cowardly complaints using the annonymity that this site affords her so that she need not support her arguements nor be recognised for them, I am unable to find myself caring about her opinions and I hope that those of you who have expressed your own distaste for her behaviour will cease to let her juvenile ramblings bother you.

    I quite like this story, and despite what seems to have become stalkerish behaviour on her behalf (go and take a look at the story You...you...Wizard) I will not be changing any parts of it.

    I am even considering a short epilogue where Draco does actually get to meet the Grangers, and yes, he will probably call them Muggles - to their faces!! Gasp! Horror!


    Report Review

  • From ANON - lilil on January 01, 2005
    3 dot (...) Just Shut up! Why dont you write some? This is FICTION. F-I-C-T-I-O-N. I read many HP Fiction. 70-80% of those story gone wild,out of Character and out of meaning of the word than this. Or some plot not even close to the book. Whats wrong with you? And why did you put your real penname. I believe you got one. Dont be shy. Or you can tell me what is your fav HP fic. So i can check it out.


    PS. Go read your HP book so you will get everything you want.


    Gerrrr. sorry everybody my english sucks. English is not my first lang.:P
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Ryu on January 01, 2005
    Excellent story! Although I was under the impression that it was going to be one-shot. But the ending seemed...unfinished. So are you planning on writing another chapter?
    Report Review

  • From on January 01, 2005
    What was awful about .'s review? . was right. The word "muggle" isn't an insult. Having Hermione react to it as if it were is ridiculous, as ridiculous as having her act like her parents being called British was an insult.

    Since the story is based on this misunderstanding of Rowling, I think . was quite right to point this out and ask that the author edit the story to have it make sense. Why do you object? Do you want Bluemidget's story to make no sense? I'd think you'd want to help her (?) rather than praise her for a story that, while hot, misinterprets the Harry Potter world.

    . didn't say for Blue to stop writing, or anything nasty. . just doesn't understand why Blue wrote a story based on an insult that wasn't insulting! I don't, either. I don't see how you can read the HP books and think the word "muggle" is an insult. Why would Hogwarts have a Muggle Studies class if the word was somehow insulting? Dumbledore wouldn't stand for it, and neither would Hermione, who takes the class.

    Keep writing, Blue, but revise the story to have Draco give a real insult, like "mudblood" or something. Please. It really doesn't make sense as it stands.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Pinkpig on December 31, 2004
    Oh my god ... I was so afraid that it was Hermionie's parents who walked in on that scene - which woul dhave been very very bad, especially if Grandma was there. Then I thouigh it was Ron or Harry - the best guy friend which would have been so much worse. Thank goodness it was Julia. Ok - my breathing is returning to normal. Aside from that brief moment of horror this was incredible. I'll never be able to look at tinsle again. And my Aunt loves teh stuff too. I'm really excited to read your next update for PV - I just re-read Chapter 37 for teh 5th time and I'm burning with suspense.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - tex on December 29, 2004
    Loved this story...they were so sad apart form each other. You really do have an amazing ability for writing. Can't wait to read more of your work.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - dracofan on December 28, 2004
    Hey! I love this story as well as your other Draco Hermione one, Pansy's Volcano. Please please please update soon, and will there be more of this one? I'd really like to see how Hermione's parents react to meeting Draco and stuff.
    Okay, UPDATE SOON!
    Report Review

  • From Amonara on December 28, 2004
    I agree whole heartedly with Padfoot. This is good one shot fic! It was hot, funny, sweet, and the embarassment was first rate. I love PV, and your writing. I can't understand why anyone would give this fic less than five stars. I've seen many less deserving fics than yours get five. This was a wonderful Christmas present and request fic. I'm sure Raffy liked it. I thought the tinsel play was very original and hot!!!

    And I will not, deign to reply to the awful review above mine. I'm just glad it was anonymous, or else...well I better behave. I won't sink down to their level.

    I think you're a wonderful, no awesome, writer whose works are incredibly well written. Please keep up the good work. I can't wait for the next chapter in PV, and I hope to see more stuff from you in the future.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - . on December 28, 2004
    Sigh.

    Might I ask why you won't revise the story to have Draco really insult the Grangers? It would make more sense. Honestly.

    Currently, it's like he's calling them British and Hermione's taking offense.

    Please revise it! I know you like your story, but don't you want it to be accurate?

    Please.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - semperputus on December 27, 2004
    I love your stories and thanks for the christmas fluff always good to have something sweet for christmas...
    I would love another chapter the meeting of the Grangers that would be cool and Hermione's reward if Draco is good would be even better
    A belated Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year
    Report Review

  • From ANON - ksinnis on December 27, 2004
    Oh wow! Merry XXXmas!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Anon on December 26, 2004
    This may possibly be the shortest review I ever left...

    Draco didn't meet the Grangers! I hope there's more! ^_^
    Report Review

  • From on December 26, 2004
    that would have been one hell of away to meet the parents.. i thought it was her parents at first, when her friend walked in though.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Padfoot the Marauder on December 26, 2004
    I read your story yesterday and when I dialed in to review it just now, my yaw dropped to the floor at what I saw... I CANNOT BELIEVE THE IDIOTS WHO GAVE YOUR STORY ONLY FOUR STARS! Honestly, that's just barbaric. I hope my rating tipped the scale. I just want to say that I love your writing trumendously. This story was lovely and soooo sexy *growl* and also soooo embarassing in the end. :-) You know, in a way one can see this story as a part of Pansy's Volcano... if you juggle a bit with the timeframe and all. Never mind, I'm babbling now. Go write the next chapter of P.V.!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Sunshine on December 26, 2004
    That was HOT.
    Report Review

T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!