Click Here!

Reviews for What a Witch Needs

By : TCardan
  • From ANON - Nicole on December 21, 2005
    I saw it too!!! It was like Ron wasn't in the picture at all. I loved it! (I can't stand Ron...sry to anyone who can)
    But anyway this story RockS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Keep up the good work!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Tiffany on December 21, 2005
    Petals, I just wanted to say that I'm ecstatic that you have a LiveJournal!!
    Now let's spread the word about WAWN even further amongst the LJ community! (I'm addicted to LJs)
    Also, concerning GOF, I totally agree with you in relation to the H/Hr chemistry within this movie. But alas, it shant be!
    I may offend several shippers by saying this, but in my opinion Ron/Hermione is a total snoozer!
    JK's mindset is to keep the Trio perpetually together, by perhaps, making them in-laws. (Let's not even discuss Harry/Ginny. Oh,the horror!)
    Ms. Rowling subliminally slashed her way through Book 6, and then it seems as if she came to her senses somewhat and said: "Oh no! I can't! Henceforth, the H/G debacle. Extremely poorly written that was. Not to mention one of the lamest break-up excuses ever. Akin to an "It's not you, It's me", type thingy, or whatever. (Harry/Luna I just LOVE!)
    I've even read a few posts concerning the fact that Harry may have been the victim of a love potion, which will be revealed in Book 7 *duh*. There was one extremely good post, which had me going through certain passages from Book 6, and they seem very credible. JK's books are sort of like mystery novels. Contextual clues abound within her writing style and my inner-sleuth finds it rather intriguing. Hermione was the culprit (without Ginny's knowledge)and I find it quite interesting that she doesn't believe that Love Potions are synonymous with the Dark Arts. I find this theory incredibly exciting, and there's so much more I'd like to mention.
    I could go on and on about this, so I'll just make my final points.
    I feel that Snape is a threat to Hermione. The fact that he re-stated the fact that Harry would INDEED regret his actions after he looked at her, unnerves me.
    Chapter 52 was brilliant, and I can't get the picture of Tonks with lime green? shoes out of my mind. I even have a feeling that Cissy may turn out to be a bit of a Mother Hen where Dudders *teehee* is concerned. Dudley with the Malfoys is just classic! Exciting reading there!
    I DO adore Draco's, as well as Harry's, possessiveness. Looking forward to your next chapter as always. (Currently incoherent)

    Remember. She wants to make them family, folks. It's all about ....that OTHER Trio.

    YOU HAVE AN LJ!! Yaaayyy!!!

    Report Review

  • From ANON - Anon on December 20, 2005
    mate yo gotta keep going. i seem to be addicted! one thing though there isnt much trust between hermione, malfoy and harry. they are all bloody possesive even at the smallest of things.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Sorceress14 on December 19, 2005
    I absolutely loved the interaction between Lucius, Narcissa, and Dudley and I can't wait to see where Dudley is off to! What will his punishment be? Let it be kinky, lol! Sorry, I'm addicted to squick fics and Dudley needs some love too! I also love overprotective!Draco, it really suits him. The love between these three is fabulous, though I do wish you would have elaborated a bit on their sex scene to give me my quick fix for the day, lol. Who knows? Maybe you'll make up for lack of sex in this chapter in the next one! HINT *cough *HINT* Please update soon!

    P.S. As for your comment on Hermione and Harry, I think that the directors are just trying to even out the shipping in the movies for those to delusional about what the books have been implying since day one. The next will probably be chalk full of R/Hr and they will alternate every so on until the true relationships become canon. You can't blame them. I know that I wouldn't want hate mail from an angry horde of Harry/Hermione shippers! But, I was totally thinking of this fic when Malfoy went into Crabbe's pants, I was screaming 'Petalsoft was right! He is bi! Of course, no one knew what I was talking about but oh well :) I also thought the same thing with all the Cedric/Harry inuendo.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Cara on December 19, 2005
    I so agree with you on the 'vibes' between Harry and Hermione. Really made me think something was going on between them. Awesome Chappie by the way!!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Cara on December 19, 2005
    I so agree with you on the 'vibes' between Harry and Hermione. Really made me think something was going on between them. Awesome Chappie by the way!!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - yomouda on December 19, 2005
    ... gross. but update. please
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Cindy Malfoy on December 19, 2005
    OMG!!!! I love your story. I'm glad that you updated finally, i've been waiting. I'm also anxious to see what is going to happen next. In regards to the movie, I agree there definitely was more chemistry between Hermione and Harry than Hermione and Ron, and what was with all the missing characters? Anyway, like I said before love the story, keep writing!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - lilycat on December 19, 2005
    Dudley is such a naughty boy. Wonder what he'll get up to? I loved his description of Narcissa and Tonks as they were in the limo. I always enjoy the witches and wizards attempts to blend in with muggle society :P

    Poor Draco. I don't imagine that would make him very happy, would it? I'm a bit nervous for Ron now!

    A wonderful chapter. I'm always delighted to see that you've updated.

    With regards to Goblet of Fire: Um, yeah. You definitely aren't the only one. Do you do livejournal stuff at all? There was much discussion of that very peculiarity when the movie came out. I personally think that the screenwriter twists the dynamics of the trio a great deal. I loved movie, but in general I don't think that they really nailed the true relationships in this film. There were a LOT of H/Hr scenes that seemed to be implying more than what is really there, at least in my opinion.

    Not that I'm necessarily complaining. It was cute, I thought. *dodges flying objects* It just wasn't accurate.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - KarenElyham on December 19, 2005
    I agree wholeheartedly regarding the GOF movie! I sensed far more of a connection between Harry and Hermoine's actors than Ron and Hermione, which I find a contrast to what is actually described in the book. Is this a subtle little hint from Ms. Rowlings? Or simply poor casting? Very interesting. Oh! And great chapter. The Dudley subplot is a very creative detour.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - AbandonedDreams on December 19, 2005
    in responce to you note, yeh i did notice how close harry and hermione was! altho it was a good movie, it was almost dissapointing. not nearly as detailed as the books. and i hated the way malfoy was humiliated. but hey! lol
    please update more often! im a big fan of this fic but i find its updated hardly ever. sorry to nag!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - SpiritOfBeyond on December 19, 2005
    LOOOOOOOVED this chappie!!! cant wait till the next one! you are such an amazing writer!!!!!!!!!!!!
    Report Review

  • From silvertears88 on December 19, 2005
    nope..i felt the vibe too...they were sooo trying to set them up. it annoyed me so bad. i was like THATS NOT HOW IT IS IN THE BOOK!!! STOP TRYING TO GIVE THE VIEWERS THE WRONG IMPRESSION..anyway...i really like this new chapter. hell i love all the chapters...
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Kris on December 18, 2005
    I agree with you totally. To me it seemed like Ron and Draco weren't as important in this movie then the others. I mean I understand why and everything but still. The bond between Hermione and Harry seemed to be stronger......Also I LOVE this story. I check it like every day to see if you've posted!!
    Report Review

  • From on December 18, 2005
    I totally agree with the GoF thing. Ohh Rons going to get his ass kicked and Draco's going to be in so much trouble with Hermione and Harry for kicking Rons ass. LOL
    Report Review

T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!