Click Here!

Reviews for Who Killed Ronald Weasley?

By : TheHogwartsPlayers
  • From ANON - CiraArana on September 27, 2005
    Interesting, interesting. Or, to be more precise: what a bloody good idea! *grins*
    Yes, I really do like the idea. I'm a huge fan of whodunnit-crime novels, and to find one in the HP-fandom is really great. Plus, I like the way it's written, i.e. the chapters from the suspects. Each gives a little more information, and with each information the story gets more and more twisted. All the complications and lies and ... really, wonderful.
    I only wonder: do you know who did it?
    ^-^

    Report Review

  • From DemonBlaze on September 27, 2005
    The chapter was great
    Report Review

  • From ANON - LMC on September 27, 2005
    Great story. Please keep going. I want to know who killed him too.
    Report Review

  • From AngelSkywalker on September 26, 2005
    This is a great fic. It kept my intrest.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - cannonfodder on September 25, 2005
    I love this, It completely captures Lucius. well done madame author.
    Report Review

  • From DemonBlaze on September 25, 2005
    The chapter was great
    Report Review

  • From ANON - NightScribe on September 24, 2005
    This is the first story I've read in full and I'm laughing my ass off! The snarky tone is perfect, I have no clue as to whodunnit and am looking forward to future chapters.
    Report Review

  • From DemonBlaze on September 24, 2005
    The chapter was great
    Report Review

  • From ANON - scully on September 24, 2005
    love it! love the format you are using with interviews, notes and newspaper articles. it is cool having a group of authors (im assuming its a group, not that you are schitzo, haha!) as well and doesnt detract from the story. interesting point of view shift for the interview with hermoine. wonder if all interviews will be from the pov of the interviewee. that would be interesting. will we be getting some sex scenes soon--either present scene or as a flashback? those could be very interesting considering the relationships among the cast of suspects! looking forward to future chapters!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Green Jellybean on September 24, 2005
    I didn't really like this chapter as much as the others. I think that it's because of the POV. Seeing the story through the eyes of an original character (Boadicea Basher) gave it a more detached feel, which I liked. All of the canon characters are OOC, but that's ok because it's how the story is (if that makes sense?). But seeing it through the eyes of an OOC canon character doesn't seem right to me. I'm also not a big fan of the first person narrative. I know two of the previous chapter used first person, but I didn't seem to mind as much because it still felt kind of detached with the OC. I definitely prefer third person, though. I also liked reading the different reports and Daily Prophet articles in the previous chapters. The story overall is an interesting idea. I'm wondering whether we won't know anything about who did it until the end of the story when the killer (or killers) is revealed, or will the number of suspects decrease as the story goes along until only a couple are left.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - June on September 24, 2005
    Ch 5 - when Hermione says "I
    Report Review

  • From DemonBlaze on September 23, 2005
    The story is really good so far, the first four chapters are funny, suspenseful and entralling. Cant wait for more!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - lilith on September 23, 2005
    As I first read this story, it reminded me of 'murder on the orient express'. Its a very old film, so perhaps you don't know it, but I hope your story continues to be as interesting as this film is! In the tradition of orient express I think that ALL suspects killed Ron, either together or one at a time. If that isn't the case, it is Neville for shure. I think Ron poisioned his girlfriend, the hemlock... and, last but not least, the murderer is always the gardener after all... ;-)
    Report Review

  • From ANON - June on September 22, 2005
    Ch 4 - well, speed users have died from overdose, but Ron could've died from the strangulation, or hemlock, or who knows what. I'm looking forward to the Hermione interview next!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Arnettra on September 21, 2005
    I am most intrigued! I like the style you've chosen to go with; I really do feel as if I'm reading the Daily Prophet getting news of this salacious story. Although Ron is my favorite character, it's an odd thrill to see him sullied up a bit. Please continue.
    Report Review

T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!