Click Here!

Reviews for Guilty as Sin

By : harriet
  • From ANON - Philomel on December 15, 2005
    *applauds* I loved this story! The ending ist TEH CUTENESS! The characters were well developed, and I liked the way Harry had to get used to this other side of him. The relationship between the three was a bit too brutal for my taste, though it suits the story fine.

    (BTW, the ending -ei sounds like egg in German, so I, being a native German, had to concentrate hard not to read "Superei" as "Superegg" - This lead my flatmate to put a sign on her door saying "Don't you dare challenge the Superei!" because it has that ssecond meaning *g*)
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Hecate18 on December 15, 2005
    I loved it!!!
    This was the fic that 'distracted' me from my coursework many many times; but I can't complain, I enjoyed every minute of reading it. ^_^
    I was persuaded to like it, although I've never been too fond of Harry/Snape pairings... there's only a few fics that have the ability, and I'm thankful I stumbled upon this one!

    ~Hecate18~
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Naz on December 15, 2005
    I loved yje entire story ab fab, i loved the portrayal of all the characters.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - LazySnake on December 15, 2005
    Actually I have read most of your stories. Mainly those with the word complete in the summary.
    I am always waiting for that word to appear than I will clear up my whole day and snuggle down to enjoy your story. They are just so delicioius.
    Sorry for being an ass and only writing one review for all the efford you have put in all your stories. I will try to review all the other stories after I have savored Guilty As Sin. Does this story have mpreg? I am a sucker for them especially if fluff is in the equation. Nevertheless all your stories are amazing.
    ^_^ Keep up the good work.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Crimson Rose-Angel on December 14, 2005
    I LOVED IT! I think there should be a sequel or something.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - QueenRissa on December 14, 2005
    First, I would like to state that I don't review FF until it is complete, so I have been a silent follower for a while. On to the review. The concept was very original and I truly enjoyed the fic. The rise (and fall) of Voldemort, Snape bringing Malfoy into the "family" to give Harry a break, all made the story addicting, and spent way to many nights up later than I should have just to keep reading. I'm not that into roughness, or Draco for that matter, but the relationship between the Superei & Inferei was fascinatiing. And, even though you stated you're not the "fluffy ending" type, having Paris sitting in the compartment with Weasley & Longbottom, was great. Brought it full circle.

    Thank you so much for sharing, and I will keep my eye out for any more HP/SS fanfiction you may post.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - tessa3 on December 14, 2005
    well that was a disturbing ending lol.. anyhoo.. OVERALL: I FUCKING LOVED IT!!!! YEs.. there were certain parts that i turly hated but then there were parts that had my eyes go like this O.O and then there were parts that mead me say DAMN and so on and so forth.. but i am sad to see it end but *shrugs* ah well.. que sera sera.. loved it
    Report Review

  • From ANON - acr on December 14, 2005
    I was kinda dissappointed in the ending, to be honest. It was too easy. I also wanted to see Harry confront Ron and Remus.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Donavon on December 14, 2005
    I hate it when one of your stories comes to an end. Write more soon.

    I loved it!!!! Draco was a whining prat but what else is new. I adored your Snape he could slap me
    around anyday.

    Best wishes HOW ABOUT A STORY FOR CHRISTMAS FOR YOUR READERS AND FANS. COME ON WE DESERVE IT
    PLEASE.........
    Report Review

  • From ANON - antipyro on December 14, 2005
    Wow! Love the ending. It kinda leads into a new adventure for Paris and Aramis, maybe with the older trio saving them from something unknown about Elith-Feratu (Sorry if the spelling is wrong - I'm going from memory here).

    Wadda' mean, you hate fluffy endings...... - this IS as fluffy as you get - NO ONE DIED! So it's a great ending!!!!

    I don't really believe the "no ideas left" story either......Your stories are cherished for their ingenuity, detail and canon-likeness, never mind the angst, humour and tragedy that pervade through them. Life is full of it and you manage to pull out what can possibly happen and make it work. Pure genius!

    Thank you sooooo much for another fine piece of work. Rest well, and don't stop writing.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - deb on December 14, 2005
    trust me this has not been done before lol

    Report Review

  • From ANON - Anon on December 14, 2005
    Thank you for this wonderful story!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Mashell on December 14, 2005
    I loved it!
    It was so fun
    reading it you always
    had something new to
    give us.

    Now for a little begging I feel compelled to do.
    Please Please Please put out the alternate ending
    that you had planned from the start. I don't know why
    but I really want to know what you were orginally going to
    do. I get that it was sad or at least not nearly as happy as
    the one you posted, but I really want to read it. Besides it's
    a way to denie the end has come to this delightful fic. I hope
    you decide to write and post the chapters for all of us who are
    to curious for our own good. Thank you for the wonderful fic.

    -Mashell
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Adorina Mae on December 13, 2005
    absolutely loved it.!!!! i think you ended it in a good spot instead of draggin it on forever. very well written and your backgrounds didn't conflict
    Report Review

  • From ANON - merry on December 13, 2005
    I LOVED this fic! Draco/Snape/Harry is my absolute fave threeway and I just adore fics that keep that snarky bite that the three of them have with each other. Well Done, Riffraff! =D

    ~Merry~
    Report Review

T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!