Click Here!

Reviews for Star-Crossed Lovers

By : slygriff21
  • From ANON - beeky63 on November 14, 2005
    My apologies. I did not see the references to Star Wars in the disclaimer. I usually skip those because we all know that the wonderful Miss Rowling wrote the Harry Potter books.

    I do however read the authors notes where such references are usually made.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Wolfie on November 14, 2005
    beeky63

    The review you left was uncalled for. If you had actually read her disclaimer she plainly states she is using lines from Revenge of The Silth.


    Also let me point our something here. This story is not plauged as you say. Plaugarism is where you copy word for word or you use a story but change the characters.

    This story is loosely based on the plot of the movie. IT is not PLAUGED! If it was she would be writing the script with the names in it. She is loosely using Hermione and Severus in the same circumstances and not as the characters from the movie. She has choosen to give them the powers from Revenge of the Silth. That is her business.

    If anyone is at fault here it is you stating as such. If this was indeed the case, which it isn't then the entire Harry Potter catergory would be plauged in one way or another so are you stating that since this story is plauged then all 4085 stories in this catergory are plauged. Please refrain from accusing an author of plaugarism if you do not have proof. Yes it seems simular but it is not compleately the same. Therefore not plauged.

    If you still feel it is as such then feel free to report her to the problems group as a plaugarist author. They in turn will tell you the same thing I did here. It is not plauged just based upon the story and/or movie. She gave proper credit where it is due and therefore she is not in the wrong.


    Wolfie

    Assistant Mod of AFF
    Report Review

  • From ANON - beeky63 on November 14, 2005
    My motto in life is to never critize unless you can do better, but I have to say that this chapter is a direct rip off from Star Wars Revenge of the Sith and that is called plagiarism.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - angel on November 14, 2005
    wow this is great i love it ... and what are severus' abilities and why is dumbledore scared of them being together ... i hope severus can stop his premonition ... ...please more i love it .. keep up the awesome work and later for now

    angel
    Report Review

  • From rush22 on November 14, 2005
    oooh i like this so far! i cant wait to find out just what exactly are severus' abilities and why dumbledore doesn't want the pair together. keep up the good work, i'll be looking foward to your next chapter!
    Report Review

T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!