Click Here!

Reviews for Hogsmeade, Circa 1826

By : TaranSwann
  • From ANON - xopoisonloveox on December 09, 2006
    wow.. i love this story. at first, i thought i wouldnt like it because i normally dont prefer dom!harry stories but this one just kinda drew me in. please continue writing!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Kyriss on November 16, 2006
    Taran,
    I've seen and read this story a few times and really hope that someday soon you'll add to it. I enjoy AU stories and appreciate the way some writers attempt a variation of historical culture. Poke your Muse and keep writing!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Snowspell on November 07, 2006
    Hi, I love your story. While it does seem that Harry isn't having quite the emotional angst I would expect from him I still think it's very realistic for him to be a natural dominant. He is in the books he's just also VERY shy. The idea that Voldemort sent them back in time is a little weak so I hope they uncover something to either strengthen the idea or change to a new hypothosis (sorry about the spelling). I think Harry and Snape are increadibly sexy in this and I love your vivid descriptions. I hope you update soon but I hope even more that you are hale and healthy soon.
    With many well wishes,
    Snowspell
    Report Review

  • From ANON - OO(drool) on September 27, 2006
    WOW!gettin all hot and botherd here...GREAT STORY UPDATE SOON!!!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - ayla on August 17, 2006
    This is absolutely brilliant!!! I love this story and saved this in my favorites to look for updates when you post them. You have yourself a new fan ~ GO YOU!!! :D:D:D


    Report Review

  • From ANON - ~Chels~ on July 15, 2006
    I really love this fic! A++++++++++++++
    Report Review

  • From curiouswriter16 on July 02, 2006
    Drayan starts contemplating all the possible meanings of the word commotion. I must admit that you've triggered some curiosity. I look forward to seeing more development with all OCs in future chapters. Just keep writing.

    D. Potter
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Bradhadair on February 13, 2006
    Now, i really don't review that often (yes, being a writer i know that is bad) but i find this story to be very interesting. I like how you have the characters and you hit to the books by using Malfoy and Dumbledor, not just taking the names and ideas to make your own story. And no matter what that one review said i do have to say this a nicely writen fanfic and at least I do not expect you to be perfect. As far as posting... again, i do write and post so... just get them as fast as you can.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Wraith on February 12, 2006
    I love it, keep going.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - evalhanne on February 05, 2006
    This is a pretty interesting story. It's different, being set in a different time and all. And kudos to you for telling off that person. Who reads fanfiction looking for historical correctness anyway? I think it's a great story and I can't wait to read more. Hope you get better soon!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - SuzieQ on February 02, 2006
    I read the other reviewer about slavery and how inaccurate your setting and just had to laugh. Obviously you touched a sore spot for that person but her criticism about historical accuracy was rather silly considering the fandom. I'll give just one example why I think so.

    In Chamber of Secrets JKR has the entrance to the chamber hidden in the girls lavatory. Now I'm far from the history expert but I know that indoor plumbing didn't exsist prior to the 1800s. Even the Roman baths didn't have that kind of running water, flush toilets, sinks etc. So we've got a castle built in about 1000 AD by the founders one of which decides to hide the entrance to his chamber in a bathroom? A bathroom that wouldn't have exsisted for another 1850 years -- at least in the style shown. Not to mention that fawcets wouldn't have lasted a thousand years. You couldn't even argue for a remodel because the plumbing necessary to create a bathroom would have revealed the entrance. Not to mention that the snake on the sink that was necessary to open the chamber had to be set up by a parselmouth. And the legend attributes the chamber to Slytherin. So trying to apply realism to HP just doesn't work.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - miss s on February 01, 2006
    NUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU! you must continue!!! Don't let any, thoughtless flamers stop you! (yeah i know some reviews can be cutting and sting quiet a bit >_
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Loonytunes on February 01, 2006
    Oh, I feel smut comming up!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Lanta on January 31, 2006
    I like this. I love this type of slavefic. As for that review you quoted in the latest chapter - yes you're OOC and historically in-accurate (I personally think you'd have been better setting it in the eighteenth century) but you covered all of that right at the beginnning by labelling it an 'AU'. So I'm perfectly happy with it all and will be checking back to read any updates :)
    Report Review

  • From ANON - dragonfly on January 28, 2006
    Wow I love your story! Oh and on what Asta said those are the people you have to learn to ignore. Mostly because the hole 'unrealistic' thing.... cuz wizards are just a normal day occurance, never mind the fact that you got a date or two mixed up.

    Asta if your reading this go get some help and stop making other people's lives difficult because you have a problem with thier work. You don't have to flame someone's work just because they got a date wrong, its rude.

    ~Dragonfly~
    Report Review

T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!