Click Here!

Reviews for It Happened One Hallow's Eve

By : Ms_Figg
  • From ANON - Ms_Figg on November 25, 2006
    David: The reason Hermione did not participate in the battle is because I saw her as more a liability than anything else, to both Harry and Severus. The rest of the school was locked inside, Hermione is a student so she was too, like Ron. She just received extra "security" because of her brilliance, bull-headedness and rule-breaking tendencies. If I believed she could have added anything more to the story I would have put her in the middle of the battle. Getting her past the castle defenses in a timely manner would have been impossible anyway. There was not enough time. Now...as to what you suppose will happen next... :::smiles and shrugs shoulders::: Maybe your prediction will be right. But I like to think total predictablity isn't a strong point with my stories. Oh, no doubt there will be a closing lemon. It's required. But the way it goes down...hmmmmm. There's the rub.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - David on November 25, 2006
    Couldn't you let Hermione play even a minor role in the battle? No, instead you have her locked away for her own "protection" like a character in a Victorian melodrama. And now I suppose we'll have all sorts of sexual shennanigans as Hermione is "punished" by Snape for her disobedience. Can't you allow Hermione the slightest trace of dignity?
    Report Review

  • From ANON - sheedy on November 25, 2006
    ROFLMAO Killed by a tree?!! Love it!!!!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Becky on November 25, 2006
    Chapter 32 pissed me off no end. What Snape did was WRONG, and his and Dumbledore's patronizing attitute towards Hermione was worse. I hope she gets him back GOOD in a future chapter. If someone had done that to me, and then acted like that when they came back, I would have told them not to touch me - and ended the relationship. For Hermione to just accept it would be a)totally demeaning b)totally out of character. Here's to sneaky, nasty revenge.
    Report Review

  • From Rumpelyssa on November 25, 2006
    I liked the last two chapters. I can't wait for anymore... is it really going to be final? *sniff!*

    I loved this story... It was brilliant.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - janeya on November 25, 2006
    Best final battle scene... ever. And, I think I've read them all. I usually nod off half-way through. Yours was interesting, had plenty of action, was original - and moreover, didn't bore me to death! Oh, yes, I have died of boredom many times reading the final battle in other fics. This was excellent!
    Report Review

  • From SorceressFujin on November 25, 2006
    Excellent!! hehe, I love how the tree killed him. Not a very glorious way to go out, is it? lol Looking forward to the next chapter... yum!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - liquidvamp on November 25, 2006
    And the award for best unbelievable death goes to...


    That was wicked :) Can't wait for more.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Catharine on November 25, 2006
    Hi there,
    Voldemort felled by a tree:). I like that! I realize that Severus delivered the final blow,but it seems fitting that even nature would deplore true evil!
    This was a particularly funny chapter!
    Catharine
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Anon on November 25, 2006
    heh. loved the chapter, especially the end of it :)
    i hope the next one is up shortly!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - angel on November 25, 2006
    man ... that was great ... crushed by the tree and kill my the ever dager that he give to sev to kill the headmaster ... hehehe i love that sev got there in time to see mione trying to leave... please please please please please please please please please please please please update soon i would love to read more ... later for now

    angel
    Report Review

  • From ANON - firewall on November 25, 2006
    I was absolutely positive you were going to have Crookshanks kill off Voldemort but loved the irony of Lucius doing it instead. I also thought having Severus do the final killing of the big V perfect...definitely not a case of overkill in this instance. BTW loved your A/N in this chapter.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Citten on November 25, 2006
    i love this story just as much as the others and with equal laughter! i also love the reacureing characters and your wonderful battles and very.....unusual deaths. but that makes them all the more fun! i also love the way you usually to always have severus protrated the domonating and loveable man! i do hope that you don't end it too hurriedly and give us lemons and a great epoligy. maybe even a sequel to this story would be fun, the future and a look at their lives (like marriage, pregency, child birth, the kids, more bad guys, and well you get the idea.) now will you please give us the lemons! :)
    Report Review

  • From ANON - takemeaway on November 25, 2006
    LMFAO!!! I LOVED that!! Talk about irony!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - septentrion on November 25, 2006
    ch 32: what a funny way to kill Voldemort! Very imaginative!
    Report Review

T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!