Click Here!

  • 1

Reviews for Silent Year

By : Windsong21
  • From Windsong21 on November 19, 2007
    Thanks everyone for your kind words!
    Report Review

  • From Happyappy on March 30, 2007
    Oh my gosh, I can't beleive Karakoff actually stood up for her! Dumbledore had to have summoned him and made him do it right? He couldn't actually have been nice by himself, could have he? I really don't like these white robed people. They seem exceptionally creul. Karakoff said that he asked the king's permission to send her, so why was she still punished? Just because they don't feel a commoner halfblood is good enough for the king's son? I guess whatever race of people they are, they have the same kind of predudices that the wizarding world has with pure bloods and half bloods. Good chapter.
    Sansa
    Report Review

  • From Happyappy on March 19, 2007
    OK, so now I am truly confused. I am sure if I am pateint you will reveal everthing as the story progresses, but I am never patient. Sorry. I guess Karacoff put rocks in the box. What a jerk! Someone really needs to hex him. Did he also know he would get her in trouble by sending her to Hogwarts? Why were the white robed figures at Hogwarts, and why were they sinking Ragu in a box? Why didn't he want her to save him? Wouldn't he have died? Will Dumbledore tell them that he ordered books, or did Karacoff make that up? If Dumbledore tells them, will it get her off the hook? Please update very soon.
    Sansa
    Report Review

  • From Happyappy on February 09, 2007
    This story gets more and more interesting. He went right thru her, she has blue blood, and a huge scar. I just want to know all about her. What are the stones for? Maybe it is something to help protect Hazelton? I am hoping she will be able to talk to Dumbledore, and maybe learn some more about her. I will be looking for the next update.
    Sansa
    Report Review

  • From Happyappy on February 08, 2007
    It is a good thing that Hazelton can run to Q. Not good for her, but good for him. Someone really needs to put that bully in his place. Karracoff too. He is a jerk! Does she seriously have to walk all the way to Hogwarts? How long would that take? It would have to take a long time, maybe her year would be up by the time she got back. I love the little dragon. The tiny room that Hazelton is in, is that where Q lives? If it is, how depressing for her. Update soon.
    Sansa
    Report Review

  • From Ravensblood on January 30, 2007
    Beautiful and captivating... I have no idea where you are going with this but I like it just the same.
    Keep up the awesomeness!


    Report Review

  • From Happyappy on January 30, 2007
    More stuff to leave me questioning. I will contain myself, and be content knowing that it will be revieled later. Well, at least one teacher is nice to her, and at least the boys in that class seem respectable. At least all is not bad in that castle. Wondering what is going on outside her library door. Guess I have to wait. Update quickly.
    Sansa
    Report Review

  • From Happyappy on January 26, 2007
    Well, we have some new charactors in the mix. Makes me wonder more than ever what these people are. Are they truly different breeds of beings, or is that just a figure of speech? What did she do that she was sentenced to a year of silence, and then why can she talk to the boy and the dragon? Too bad he loves Q, and is (or at least it seems) being accosted by an elder. She is so lonely and sad, it is a good thing she made herself a dragon, at least it gives her some company. I would be afraid too, if I were stuck at that dark cold dismal depressing school. It would give me the creeps. As for gym class swimming in the lake, if I were her, I would never go there again. Hopefully she won't be made to do so. Keep up the good work. I will be watching for updates.
    Report Review

  • From Happyappy on January 24, 2007
    Wow, Q is quite an interesting being. I surely wouldn't want to swim in that lake with the killer fish, Do they loose many students in a year? It was so nice to see her show some kind of emotion. She sure showed that idiot potion master a thing or two, Maybe he will have learned his lesson, and leave her alone now. It was amzing that she made a dragon. Was it real, or will it fade away over time since it was made with a potion. If it is real, people may think twice before they bother her. A dragon would be an intimidating pet. Please update soon.
    Report Review

  • From Happyappy on January 22, 2007
    Burr, I can not imagine swimming in a cold lake like that.Obviously, the cold dooesn't seem to bother Q. The heat does seem to bother her slightly. Makes me wonder again what she is, but I will be patient for it to come out in the story. I also want to know what forest she came from, and why she is so timid and will not talk to any one. Sorry, I always ask a million questions, most of which if I was just patient enough would come out in the story. The second boy was quite funny with his "I'm not worthy" and teach me comments. Update quickly please.

    Sansa
    Report Review

  • From Happyappy on January 19, 2007
    Wow, what a dark and dismal school. I feel bad for that poor girl to be stuck there. Who are these "others", and why did they stick the poor girl there? I do hope something nicer will happen to her there to improve her life some. It was kind of hinted, ay maybe some type of relationship with the third year that she healed, so, just how old is she? Is she something different than a witch, since she can do wandless magic? I will be looking for updates.

    Sansa


    Report Review

  • From Windsong21 on January 13, 2007
    Thank you very much! ^_^.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Anon on January 12, 2007
    i thought this was really good for your first time can't wait to read the enxt one
    Report Review

  • 1
T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!