Click Here!

Reviews for Nights of Gethsemane

By : starcrossedkayla
  • From ANON - Guura on April 28, 2010
    I have to say I really enjoy this story. It is by far my favorite story in the Harry Potter-universe.
    It is very creative and the plot is exciting and interesting, not to mention that you are a very talented writer who makes the text seem fluid and alive in a poetic sort of way.
    The latest episode really made me begin to wonder whether Tom is completely honest with what he claims Snape to be doing and feeling. I don't know who to believe, although what Tom has stated does make sense. However, a part of me still believes Snape's the good guy so I don't want to judge him too soon. I guess I'll just have to wait and see what happens.
    Hope you update soon!
    Report Review

  • From mrequecky on April 24, 2010
    Loved the chap, but I'm also a bit confused right now, probably like Harry... I believe in Snape though.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - alexia on April 20, 2010
    please update soon! thanks
    Report Review

  • From SailorsMoons on April 18, 2010
    Wow this has been an awesome weekend (though I've neglected a ton of work I must do), but I must say this story has me heart wrenched. I could feel from early on around chapter 25 that this was probably not going to be the type of story where at the end Harry and Snape end up perfectly together and live happily forever. And now I've thought of every possible way that they could end up together and to no success do I see it working (hope you prove me wrong!)..

    And at first I was terrible confused, I still am a bit (and if I'm wrong, then I'm major befuddled). But my speculations: The dreams (well current non sex involved dreams) are dreams from the Horcrux right? The horcrux inside Harry is what has fallen in love with him and the Horcrux is saying that Snape is actually the one that is keeping Harry there all along. I kind of don't understand that because I do believe Voldemort wants him.

    But that's where I think the Horcrux inside Harry currently is being blocked off from revealing anything to Voldemort, hence Snape hasn't been killed yet. I think Snape's magic along with what was placed in Harry's cell by Voldemort is preventing this from happening along with Harry's Occlumency.

    I also think Snape is trying to possible detain Harry because he knows Harry is a Horcrux (I'm saying that because you seem to be following closely to the book, but at the same time drifting and in the book Snape knew from early on Harry must eventually die).

    I think Snape is trying to thwart this because at first his love for Lily that was too strong to let her child die, but now because he has genuinely fallen in love with Harry. And he's protecting him by controlling him (which Harry seems to hate a lot).

    So, while I am anxiously awaiting the next chapter, I am terrified to have Snape and Harry leave each other (which seems like the inevitable -__-, ). I also since book 5, have hated the Ginny/Harry ship, it's possibly the most horrible pairings I have ever seen.

    Oh and that's another reason why I don't necessarily think the Snape relationship won't work. He "thinks" he loves Ginny a lot. While, going from the book, they haven't really spent a lot of time together. Especially not as much as he spent with Snape.

    Anyways, this was kind of me rambling about my confusion and theories. But I love your story. I normally don't read torture fics in general, but I always saw this one, and was just in a reading mood and had to read this story. I also liked the references to the books, it helps that I read a lot of them because now I think I understand Snape's character a lot. And I hope you still plan on writing this story from Snape's POV. At first I thought, it would just turn out like a summary of this story, but because of the past few chapters I'm dieing to know what Snape has been thinking the whole time. Ahh!! You've completely captured me.

    Report Review

  • From Gypsii on April 11, 2010
    BRILLIANT! But why must Snape lie to Harry?! Or, why should Harry trust Tom? Hm...
    Report Review

  • From AngelNarcissa90 on April 05, 2010
    Wow. I like this story. Great sex scene! Keep up the good work.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Anon on April 01, 2010
    I am running out of worthy enough praise for you! You are just such a stunning author, one that got me into Snarry in the first place and every single syllable of your work grips me. I cannot wait to see where this story ends up and as ever, an amazing chapter, I shall struggle to wait patiently for the next!
    Best wishes!
    Shigure-san
    x chuu x
    Report Review

  • From Cathartesaura on March 31, 2010
    I really like how you've maintained a sense of purpose in this story - I still feel like it's going somewhere, even after so many chapters. And I love their teasing, playful relationship here, although I'm afraid Tom is going to spoil it. Great job, this story keeps on at the same level of perfection and that's really hard to do!
    Report Review

  • From serenagold on March 28, 2010
    This was probably the best sex scene you've written between the two of them. Too bad it had to end with a bit of distrust. Now I'm not sure just what will happen.


    Keep up the great work!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Sarah on March 23, 2010
    holy fuuuck that was guh sop hot... god seriously... and u end it there? ur really mean u know? so please update soon!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Anon on March 21, 2010
    DUnno if i reviewed this chapter yet but if I have nevermind I'll review again! I'm so nervous everytime you post a new chapter because I can sense the end may be nigh, and I so hope both Snape and Harry get a happy ending. This story has progressed so well and so have Harry's feelings, the way you have changed him was so natural and flawless that I almost missed it!
    As always, astonishing! Cannot wait for the next one!
    Shigure-san
    x chuu x
    Report Review

  • From anniea on March 17, 2010
    ok so i've spent the past 4 days reading this story, i have to agree with the earlier readers: when harry and snape were training it got kinda old fast! i was actually happy when harry was tortured, by the way........the BDSM scene, even though Harry was terrified....was hot! but now moldy-voldy is in love with harry?! is it a ruse? my head hurts from thinking about it! when i first saw this story up on the site i thought :Ugg another "lets torture harry" story so i stayed away from it but after reading all 56 chapters in 4 days, i like it! update soon *kisses*
    Report Review

  • From serenagold on March 09, 2010
    Excellent chapter! Keep up the good work!
    Report Review

  • From mrequecky on March 07, 2010
    Yay, specially loved the flirting :D
    Report Review

  • From ANON - tribebohemian on March 06, 2010
    I absolutely love these two chapters just as much as I love everything else that came before. Thank you for staying the course with this.

    That said, I'm slightly confused about Harry's "(not)Dream" and his lack of response to it. While I'm pleased that he doesn't jump the gun and immediately suspect Snape and throw away all the trust that's been built between them... I just wonder why there seems to be no reference to the dream in the chapter that follows. I felt like I'd missed a chapter or something. But of course I still thought these were excellent.
    Report Review

T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!