Click Here!

Reviews for Hermione Granger and the wishing stone

By : fatedsoul
  • From ANON - Luvtracker on August 09, 2012
    Well this was a grave waste of time
    Report Review

  • From Trelweny on July 04, 2012
    Fascinating story. I can really see the characters turning out this way in this new situation. Is it terrible of me that I can more easily believe Harry and Ron became utter prats more than I can the twins? Although the twins are natural pranksters it hurt reading they'd do something so potentially deadly. I'm just glad their exploits were only passing comments on past instances, and that I don't have to keep reading about them being such.

    But High Ones! Even being able to see Harry as a spoiled prat I didn't think he'd go so far as rape! Honestly... he better get his just desserts for such a terrible dead! And to think he intended to blame it on DRACO...! :growls: I don't like Thinking the names I feel he deserves to be called.

    I'd love for this to have a happy ending. It would be tragic to save all those lives only to Not have a happily ever after.

    Thanks so much for writing!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Hermyoneminusone on March 03, 2012
    This is soooo good! I read it all in one sitting! I usually find it very hard to believe the plot of a Dramione story, but your idea is just so clever. I always try to justify a relationship between the two but I always fall short. An alternative universe really does tie it all together and it makes it really believable for me. I only ask for one thing: MOAR DRAMOINE SEXY TIME! That shower day-dream was especially evil. :( I also have one question: Dumbledore and Tonks and all the other people seemed to have neglected the fact that Hermione was raped... surely madame Pomfrey would have figured that out and told the aurors?? Please update soon! I can't wait for the next chapter! :D
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Hi there on March 03, 2012
    Not sure what to think of this story, really. The lastest events threw me off a little, because I didn't expect the story to be like this a all, since it started out as a rather light hearted and sweet story. Guess, we'll all have to wait and see where you're taking this. Hopefully there will be less drama and more love and happiness :)
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Gryffindork on February 24, 2012
    I don't like the direction that Hermione Granger and the Wising Stone has taken at all. I loved how the story started out and the idea of an alternate reality and the whole friendship/relationship Hermione and Draco had. It was really sweet.
    But this sudden plot change and drama, was not a good idea at all. Too bad, I really liked this story, but I don't think I'll continue reading it. And the last chapter where you decided to do some damage control, did not make up for the damage done to the story either. Bad enough that you had Harry rape her, but then the whole thing with Pansy and having Draco in Azkaban? Why? Why? Why? And having Draco being all wimpy,pathetic and letting himself being blackmailed by Pansy... Draco, the character you created,potrayed so well... Why would you destroy a strong character you made just like that?
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Nathoca Malfoy on February 21, 2012
    I already see Hermione blackmailing Rita Sketer with her unregistered animagus form. Please, take Draco out of Azkaban! And do it fast! Hermione also needs remember What Potter have done. Harry is horrible! He needs his punishment! Kisses.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - RashidaJewel on February 21, 2012
    YAY!! I hope you have more chapters ready soon, its so good.
    Report Review

  • From goldhorse on February 20, 2012
    Well, I like the story so far and I would love to review the last chapter... but I can't read it! Could you please reformat it so it isn't a huge wall of text?
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Ginzo on February 09, 2012
    This is a very very mysterious fan fic, i can't wait to see what will happen next, Please I implore u to not stop writing this as it is too good to stop halfway through, I hope hope hope to god that Draco isn't blamed for this somehow and it is proven that Potter was under Pansy's influence as that would make a whole lot more sense lol. But even if he wasnt under that influence i can still understand harry doing this as this reality is basically the opposite reality loll, this fanfic is fantastic, keep the good work, cant wait for the next chapter :)
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Lizzz on January 20, 2012
    I started reading this last night and had to finish it today. I really have to wonder what you're thinking when you took the fic in this direction... but I will have to trust you. Please, please, please update soon!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - LuvLeeLinna on January 18, 2012
    I just started on the story, and I want to I'm 'dissapointed' and no longer interested but that last chapter just made me more curious about what's going to happen next. I'm craving this; I wonder how Harry's parents will act, are they the foil to the AU Hermione left behind? Will they cover their 'precious' son's mistakes. Or are they truly good natured? Would they think it was just considering his father? Will Nymphadora take her cousin being framed for what happened to Hermione? Will Hermione Ever rememebr? Or will she believe it, if they told her lies? I am too interested in the supporting characters it's not even funny! I want to know more, this is an Alternate Universe, Harry and Ron are no longer the people they have always been. And the ANGST, the sweet, sweet, anxiety, that you have be stilled with that cliffhanger. Love it! Please, you wonderful writer, grace your story with an update when you can. I will follow this story like the lamb that followed Mary.
    Report Review

  • From TANKGIRL on December 24, 2011
    I can't wait to find out what happened
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Dramione Fan on December 09, 2011
    Your story started out really good, but the last chapters were really disappointing. I can't understand why you would use -I know this is gonna sound very harsh and I'm sorry- cheap plots like s.o. getting raped and s.o. being a sex slave (or whatever Draco is to Pansy). What a way to ruin a perfectly good story just create a shock effect.
    Your great story just turned into one of those horrible soap operas.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - OK_what_was_that? on December 05, 2011
    I've been following this story for a while now and have to say that it used to be one of my favorite Dramione stories. But unfortunately the last two chapters (especially the last one) totally killed the story for me. I mean, why on earth did you have to throw in that rape scene? Was it really necessary to create drama for your story in that way? And what's up that weird Parkinson-Draco-plot? Wish you would delete those things.
    Report Review

  • From margotlefaye on December 03, 2011
    You said you'd post warnings as appropriate. And then we get this freakin' RAPE chapter where it isn't even the pairing we're here to read about it with NO FREAKIN' WARNING.

    Took me totally out of the story and I honestly don't know if I want to come back. Not because I haven't read well done fics in which Hermione has been violated by another character within a Dramione story, but because as at least one other reviewer has said, this came out of nowhere. Harry was a prat, and possessive, but this was over the top. I was interested in Draco's secret and Hermione's growing relationship with him. Unexpected plot twists are usually wonderful things, but they have to be well set up. There's a difference between being unexpected and coming out of left field.
    Report Review

T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!