Click Here!

Reviews for A Different Kind of Magic--UNDERGOING EDIT

By : Remarkable
  • From ANON - Tito on September 19, 2010
    this chapter is sick, i hate this kind of behavior unless she was drugged.

    i loved the story before, but now ....... unless it gives reasonable explanation in the next few chapters, i think i wont read it anymore.
    Report Review

  • From ANON - sandlapper on September 19, 2010
    I got to say, I can't believe Hermione did that. Especially after the things Rasbastan said to her and Severus at Hogwarts? Was I mistaken in that he scared her? All she could think about was sex? I know this is SS/HG which is my favorite, but I hope when Severus finds out what she did he ditches her. It certainly didn't take long for her to lose her self respect and mine and I thought she cared about Severus. Gotta say I am very disappointed in this turn of events. I assume there is a reason for it so will keep reading, but...wow.
    Report Review

  • From JanisJ on September 13, 2010
    Hey, I just started this story yesterday and have been getting nothing productive done in real life! I have been glued to the screen and utterly ensnared! (completely captivated in the nicest way :) I really love all the unique ideas you are coming up with and all the political plots and intrigue, not to mention new takes on the character's histories and motivations-- Can't wait for more!
    Report Review

  • From HarryGinny4eva on September 13, 2010
    Well... well... I'm honestly not sure what to think right now. I know Severus didn't take or hurt Teddy. I know Remus is not Remus. I know I'm still angry with Minerva. And, I know neither Hermione, nor Severus deserve all this awfulness. You say there's more pain and upset to come? Sigh... Okay, I will still be here. Thanks for a moving update! HG4eva
    Report Review

  • From HarryGinny4eva on September 13, 2010
    Hermione and Rabastan?! No, no and NO!! The thought gives me the shivers. And, good for her for not allowing him to contintue to wallow in his own failure and misery. I just with she would get the help she needs so that she can stop hurting herself. I hate that life and Minerva have brought Severus so low. :-(

    But, wait! Does that mean he got his magic back in time to save Teddy?! Fingers crossed and REALLy glad I don't have to wait for my answer. :-) Off to read the next update. Thanks again, HG4eva
    Report Review

  • From HarryGinny4eva on September 13, 2010
    Hi again. I am so glad her homecoming was nice and warm, even if Severus' wasn't. It's sad to see that he can't find any happiness and is willing to throw what little life gives him away. And, I am so sorry to know Harry and Ron had a falling out and that Ron hadn't been back. I guess the trio is over for good. Sigh... But, yay for Ginny being alive and well and back in Hermione's life. She needs a friend. Why does that last sentence scare me? lol Off to read the next one... HG4eva
    Report Review

  • From HarryGinny4eva on September 13, 2010
    Hi there. I'm back from vacation and get to read all of your updates now. Yay! I hoe Hermione's life is easier at the Burrow than I suspect it will be. And, I, for the first time ever, want to punch Minerva in the face for her callousness. Way to kick a man when he's down. Sheesh! Off to read the next one. :-) Thanks, HG4eva
    Report Review

  • From ANON - sandlapper on September 06, 2010
    I got to say...I am still loving this story, but the more I read the less I am liking Minerva and even remus! Update soon!
    Report Review

  • From HarryGinny4eva on August 31, 2010
    Hey there. I finally got to get caught up on this story. I am so sorry her pain and confusion are so great and her self-esteem so low that she feels hurting herself if her only option. I am also sad that she is so genuinely happy to be going to the Weasleys. I don't like knowing how miserably unhappy Severus is either, but at least he holds no such allusions that their life is going to get better. Watching her crushed again is going to hurt. But, I think I am ready. Thank you for allowing them a glimmer of happiness for a moment with each other. I don't think they're going to get a lot more chances to be together any time soon. You write this really well, but at the end of each chapter I feel like I should give you a hug. lol Thank you once again, HG4eva
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Daughter of a serpent on August 08, 2010
    I really like this story so far and I really want more, hmm don't think Severus will be too happy about Hermione self harming :( I like how you have brought Rabastan into the mix and you have brought all the other characters out really well, with some good humour in there :) keep up the good work!
    Report Review

  • From Padfootsgrl on August 08, 2010
    They can't be seperated!!!!
    Report Review

  • From on August 07, 2010
    Well, now we know why Minerva is having problems: She is acting like a manipulative bint! Sad thing is that apparently she hasn't realized that is what is turning everyone against her. Minerva seems a little OoC in this story. Severus? About what I'd expect. Lupin? Again, OoC...... he was a wimp with James and Sirius so I really don't get how he grew a pair so fast. Hermione? Kinda OoC in the latest chapter, but then again, I can understand her self hurting.
    Report Review

  • From HarryGinny4eva on August 02, 2010
    Well, no, I guess not. Sigh... Only pain and misery for them, huh? And, now Rabastan to watch out for, too? I'm actually scared of the rest of The Order now. I fear them going to The Burrow almost as much as them staying at the castle. So, is Harry a bad guy now, too? I am so sad for them; misery behind them and ahead of them. Merlin, I hope you're a happy ending type writer! Okay, now I have to go find a happy easy story. This one is great and intriguing and I wouldn't suggest changing a thing, but it's not a good bed time read. lol Thank you and please update again soon. HG4eva
    Report Review

  • From HarryGinny4eva on August 02, 2010
    I just noticed you updated and I missed it! Eek! But, joy! I get to read 2 in a row! :-) I am so sorry they had to go through with all that. Part of me is angry at Harry for going through with it, but the other part understands his position and is glad he at least won't tell about what he saw. For the first time in any story, and I've been reading fics for several years, you've done something no one else has done. You've made me so angry with Minerva that I am close to hating her. What she did and said and how she acted with Severus were unconscionable! She was such a beyotch! I get that you need to make sure he's on your side, and I get that he hasn't been the nicest of people or the most welcoming individual, but to abuse him like that, physically, mentally, emotionally, and finally verbally?! I am appalled at her and don't know if any of it can be forgiven. I just hope Hermione remembers it and puts Minerva in her place when she can function, talk and is back to herself. No one who's done all he has and who's suffered as much as he's suffered, deserves that. Even Harry, who hates him, had more compassion! And, as if they haven't suffered enough, Rabastan is now waiting for them? Good lord! Okay, I need to go read the next one and I am hoping it ends better than this one for them. Sigh... will they ever not be hurt?

    HG4eva
    Report Review

  • From singingmelody20 on July 29, 2010
    I am really enjoying your story!! I have always been a fan of Severus and Hermione pairings! ^_^ I'm excited for the next chapter!!
    Report Review

T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!