Click Here!

Reviews for the room of requirement

By : evil-minded
  • From SteveSettler on August 31, 2012
    you know, it is a bit unfair, Severus knowing who justharry is, but Harry not knowing who the Darkmaster is. I noticed when Severus called Harry "Potter" and not "justharry" in the privat dialog, but well, I guess it's much more interesting this way :D
    otherwise, it's still a great chapter, except for Dumdork, I would love it to hit his head with a baseball
    and well, you did notice that there's a story missing? you deleted it? what happened?
    Report Review

  • From Kayrox133 on August 24, 2012
    Hi. Regarding Chapter 5 Dumbledore is such a jerk. The way he is leaning forward, hanging on Severus's answers, it is almost like he is Rita Skeeter listening in for the next bit of gossip. UGH!
    Looking forward to when Vernon will get his own.
    Report Review

  • From bloodshound on August 24, 2012
    hooli doolie, is dumbles TRYING to make another dark lord?! Leaving a vulnerable person in an environment he KNOWS he gets abused in?! Seriously, whats the point of saving his life if he loses his will in the meantime. If Har ever learns that dumbles knew he'll never trust an adult again.
    I do hope sev isn't just going to leave it at that... Har deserves better. No matter WHAT dumbles says, Har can't stay there. hell, a house with Fidelous (or however you spell that) on it would be safer.
    Report Review

  • From jujukitty on August 24, 2012
    another wonderful chapter, i am thoroughly enjoying this story :) and sev finally pushes enough to make harry slip up and spill about what's really been going on. and snape actually went to dumbles about it, and of course gets told to just sit back and wait. know that's not going to go over well. wonderful work, keep it up :)
    Report Review

  • From JeanMcIory on August 23, 2012
    you know it's hard to do a fic about a chat room, but I still think you managed very well. love it
    and your reviews didn't always work because you gave the wrong security code, my dear Steve *looool*
    Report Review

  • From SteveSettler on August 23, 2012
    I recognize your chat client, it's the one you use in real life too, isn't it?
    hope you had a nice holidays, despite the mud you've had to fight your way through *lol*
    hopw you'll update this tomorrow
    Report Review

  • From moodysavage on August 12, 2012
    I love this story. Just totally love it. I started rereading it when I saw you put up another chapter :)

    I love seeing the protective side of Severus. I know we've seen glimpses and parts in the moves but I always wanted more... and this story is WONDERFUL with that. He really wants to protect his students.
    Report Review

  • From HeartStar on August 11, 2012
    oh poor harry !
    Report Review

  • From bloodshound on August 11, 2012
    a couple of typos and misused words but on the whole not bad. crap, the sooner they get har out the better.
    Report Review

  • From JeanMcIory on July 20, 2012
    you know, I DO remember such nonsense in this chat room of yours!
    loved the chapter, and the story and I hope you'd continue soon, but knowing you, you'll be at Wacken first, and after that you'll be busy with NaNo, so I guess that no, it won't be continued anytime soon, but well, we'll have to live with that, won't we? anyway, I love your work
    Gryffindor!
    Report Review

  • From SteveSettler on July 20, 2012
    again you had me astound, about how well you managed bringing the nature of a chat room over to your readers, the fun of it but the seriousness of it too, how different people in there might react and - well, it's just been great, loved it
    Report Review

  • From jujukitty on July 15, 2012
    i'm really enjoying this story! and i loved the little running joke they had going in the chatroom, having participated in something like that in the past, you do wind up do some of the silliest things. and snape's starting to learn more about harry, and even as he does and he thinks of visiting his own students and the reasons why, he hasn't quite translated that over to visiting harry yet... and i can't wait til he does. keep up the good work, i can't wait for more :)
    Report Review

  • From moodysavage on July 13, 2012
    I was so excited when I saw a new chapter up. I find this story idea so appealing. The story isn't rushed and I like how you have balanced the chat room. It feels relaxed but it still brings up the plot problem of Snape finding out more about what Harry is really like and him home situation. I also really like how Snape looks out for his students like with the home visits. With his childhood it was probably something that he feels strongly about.
    Report Review

  • From bloodshound on July 13, 2012
    pity that concern doesn't extend to har and his mob just yet. hopefully it will in future.
    Report Review

  • From jujukitty on July 13, 2012
    this is really cool, i like the whole idea behind it as well as tossing snape into the situation blind and making him readjust his views on his students. keep up the good work, i can't wait to see more :D
    Report Review

T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!