Adult-FanFiction.org : Harry Potter

Reviews for Havoc of the Opera

By : Roman

From foxracerchick129 on May 05, 2005
Roman, I swear, I cannot put into words how incredibly amazing this fic was. It was absolutley beautiful, and even though it was very sad, I thought that it was perfect. Not saying that i would have minded a happy ending, lol, but i truly did LOVE this fic. It kept me up late for nights in a row either reading it or just thinking about it. It is truly the best fic i have read so far, and now my all time favorite. Thank you so much for writing this
Report Review
From ANON - Maq on April 25, 2005
Ah, this was actually my second read-through, and considering the recent scare that AFF might be gone for good, I thought I wouldn't take your lovely piece of art for granted anymore and review this time. The first time I read "Havoc", I had never seen/ heard "Phantom of the Opera", but I still found the plot to be wonderfully enchanting. This time, I was equipped with my soundtrack. The emotional quality of your writing paired with the songs made the experience even more pleasurable. I actually was on the verge of tears at one point. My only critiques about this story are the misspellings and typos; usually I won't read a story with these things in them, but your idea was so good that I stuck it out and thoroughly enjoyed myself. Thank you!
Report Review
From ANON - Miki on April 14, 2005
Ok so like i check my other e-mail something i have not done in forever. and i see you sent me and e-mail.. and i am like "ROMAN!!!!" so i skip everything i have to read what you have to write.. then i start reading everything on the page... aww.. you are so sweet.. really. it's my my fault you wrote sucha brilliant story that i could say nothing bad about it at all. i miss reading it... i have to save the whole thing to my computer all over again too... hmm.. tho i still wish they would have ended up together in the end... that would have been nice. i hope you get this. e-mail me sometime my new e-mail addy is with this review. later roman..

Miki
Report Review
From ANON - eruwen on April 12, 2005
the Gryffindors, who
Report Review

From ANON - The Charmed One on March 10, 2005
Hi!
It's really nice to hear, that you enjoyed my reviews :D Hmm.. actually I think I am starting to like slash stories because I read this and liked it so well.. heh, kind of funny, huh? So, are you planning on writing a new story soon? If you are, email me when first chapter is up, and I'll make sure I read it!

~The charmed one
Report Review

From ANON - Iani on March 09, 2005
>I miss
Report Review

From ANON - Lioncourt on February 27, 2005
HOW COULD YOU???!!!
Report Review

From ANON - Lioncourt on February 27, 2005
I feel like dying. That. Was the most. Cruel ending. I have ever read. I swear it's true. I'm absolutely heartbroken. Altough I must confess that you are a hell of a writer. WOW. I cant recall one single time I have been so extremely moved by a fanfiction, ever. Why do you have to be so damn good? *sobs pitifully* It will take days for me to get over this ending! It pains me to say it, but the ending really was astonishing. I guess Ron have to kill Snape then...he promised he would. Cant say I blame him. And I find that I have developed a stange and very strong disliking for Dumbledore.
I guess you've figured it out by now, but I would be more than thrilled if you wrote a sequel.
Report Review

From ANON - koriandrkitten on February 24, 2005
wow. I think thats the only word to properly describe this story. I saw POTO in the theaters twice in the theater and the second time I could see where you were coming from with your choice of characters. I hold nothing but respect for you. You rule.
Report Review

From ANON - eve on January 30, 2005
i read this and i like it, but damn, it's getting annoying seeing this pop up on the recently updated page when there's nothing new!
Report Review

From ANON - moi on January 29, 2005
Like "Quills" much? :)
Report Review

From Nem on January 24, 2005
"The Announcement"
Interesting beginning. Well written, though AU (no mention of Voldemort etc.). Interesting to see how you'll do this. Humour up ahead? Nice to see them squabbling bout the play they'll choose... ABout pairings: well, we'll see, won't we? :)
Report Review

From ANON - Quicksylver on January 22, 2005
Wonderful Story!

I have to admit that i was one of the people who wished for a happy ending but the only way that would be plausible is if voldemort would suddenly drop dead. The ending you wrote however was just right, inevitably sad with just a little hope for the future. I must say that your story made me go back and listen to my Phantom of the opera highlights soundtrack. I loved it.

the story line kept you thinking and wondering and Severus as the Phantom was sexy as hell. you had me laughing and crying and staying up until 2:30 am cause i coudln't stop reading. I will be sure to look out for other works from you. keep up the good work!
Report Review

From ANON - E-M on January 20, 2005
Came here from ETC. I could not stop reading! I felt the end to be very fitting. Very, very good.

The overall impression I got was very good, but there were a few occasions I found the choise of words to be a bit too "American". But don't put too much stock into what I'm saying, I'm not British myself (Swedish), it was just a feeling I got. You also seem to have a bit of a problem with formatting (maybe?), as quite a number of words throughout the story are unintelligible.

I am very impressed with how you kept the characters IC. Keep writing, you are good at it.
Report Review

From ANON - betty on January 20, 2005
thanks Roman. Such a great, touching, painful fanfiction! I really love it! I was totally shocked when you connet HP/SS with the Phantom of the Opera which is being on in my city. Even I don't want this fanfiction to end.
I love the pairing of HP/SS! I am lloking forward to your works.
Report Review

1

2

3

4

5