Click Here!

Reviews for Once in a Blue Moon (COMPLETE)

By : LouisaB
  • From Recordkeeper on January 08, 2012
    what a journey. I cried all the way through this story. I loved the whole thing. It was romantic, tragic, and surprising. well written if a tad long for my tastes. But still very good. I dont think i ever want to know if tragedy struck for the potters later and what happened to harry and sirius. I am perfectly happy with not knowing. this was a beautiful story and i am SO GLAD it got a happy ending. Thank you very much for this story. i only found it 2 days ago and ive been reading ever since. I am going to sleep now.
    Report Review

  • From ktgymnastics on April 08, 2011
    This was an amazing story:)
    Report Review

  • From redeyedemon on February 07, 2011
    Bah! I know the story's over, but... I really just had to come back and say I loved it, and I'm so glad it was completed. I'm so unahppy reading multi-chapter stories that don't get completely, even though I'm so guilty of it myself as a writer.

    But this story especially. I was so hooked, and I cried, and laughed and generally got far to into a story, that was based off a series that I'm already overly obsessed with. What can I say? The Harry Potter series has been a part of my life since I was seven, maybe eight, and I love it, and most spin off's of it. And, werewolves have always been my thing, and a story so based around the rights of creatures most people writed off as half-breed monsters, it just made my little furry heart sing.

    On a side note, not all Slytherins look out for only themselves... Hah. Just to stand up for me house, but most of us are rather useless as a general rule.

    Again, I'm really glad this story was completed. I'd have been seriously disappointed, and probably come after you if it hadn't. Anways, just thought I'd let you know, I loved it, and I'm rambling on because I read all seventy-seven chapters, and bottled up my review until now... So... Loved it. I'll read a sequal if I find one.

    Until next time.
    Alena
    Report Review

  • From Calcifer on January 15, 2011
    I'm impressed. I reread this chapter (after reading the minor friendly version) and I'm awed at how seamless your edits are.

    Keep up the good work!

    ~Angel
    Report Review

  • From ANON - alex on April 21, 2010
    Hi there :)
    Well, I'm pretty sure you hear this often, but your story was the best I've read in quite a while. It got me glued to the computer untill I've finished it. Well...trouth is I should've been learning for a mid-term exam in Chemistry, but I barely managed to learn at all, being too busy reading this. It is hardly a fanfic, more like a novel ;) And enjoyable all the way
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Maria on March 26, 2010
    oh wow! I don't read fics as often as I used to, partially because the older I've gotten the more I've realized how much of them are really not very good. But this was excellent! You held me captive for two days in my bedroom. Ah! And of course, I'm having a break-up and a lot of the relationship stuff I could relate to so well. I especially liked the Romulus thing. Like, for a while I suspected he was still in Azkaban, but I just got really involved in the rest of the story, so that when he was released it was a very pleasant surprise! And I also liked the moral ambiguity of Rita Skeeter. This deserves to be a classic among HP slash fics, for sure.

    so thanks very much and wonderful work! I intend to read whatever else you've got as soon as I've posted this review.
    Report Review

  • From Visitkarte on February 18, 2010
    I enjoyed this story greatly, even if it had its lengths and it wasn't always all that clear what was going on. Great plot, great second- and third-stories, and the first Rita I liked and still was believable. Thanks a lot for the adventurous journey!
    Report Review

  • From Avaloniex on February 08, 2010
    This was...sheer amazing. ~Huggles~
    Report Review

  • From ForgottenPrincess on January 11, 2010
    This story is just simply amazing. I am sad that it is over and i have to look for a new one to read. I don't think it will be easy to find a story that comes to par with this one. I would love to read the M-preg sequel if you ever do write it. *is hopeful* Although the knowledge that their would have been a sequel is at least some comfort. Its odd, when the story first started i thought Sirius' father was nicer then his mother. But as the story went on I came to feel the other way. Even though neither of them were very good. I think she loved Sirius even if she could not let go of her beliefs enough to really show it to him. I would love to see her reaction if Remus and Sirius have a child. The blacks go on but not in the family tree. My question is why didn't Sirius see the obvious solution to his polyjuice problem. Black should become the girl, Remus likes both and the full moons will not be a problem and the chance of the child having the furry issue is also reduced. Now i kind of want to read girl!sirius/remus het.....and odd feeling.
    Well this story was just amazing! Thank you for writing it. I am so glad that you finished it. So many a good story is never completed. Like finding a book with the last half missing. Thanks!

    babay_bunny@yahoo.com
    Report Review

  • From ForgottenPrincess on January 10, 2010
    This is such a sad chapter!!! I am crying!
    I love this story!!!!

    ch60
    Report Review

  • From ForgottenPrincess on January 10, 2010
    57
    OMG! your remus is so frustrating. I want to ring his neck. He goes from being a complete stubborn ass to a angst ridden ass. He makes me want to scream.
    Report Review

  • From ForgottenPrincess on January 09, 2010
    chp 53

    I think this might be the first and last time i ever think or write this. But I keep on hoping that Siruis will just tell Reamus no and mean it. I know he loves him. But he is acting like one of those annoying girls who stays with her bastard "boyfriend" when everyone knows he should leave him. I wonder if at some point I can ever feel that Remus has redeemed himself to be worthy of Siruis. I never read a story like this with them. I have to admit its good. good enough to get me really REALLY disliking... my favorite character in Harry Potter-verse of AU in this case.
    Report Review

  • From ForgottenPrincess on January 07, 2010
    I just realized how much a hufflepuff Romulus really is loyal. Poor Remus I wonder how he is going to deal living in the woods. On another note I really hate Firenze sister. To betray her own father, for her man... not only that but her brother too. Either way I'm off to read more of this story!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - qwerty on November 24, 2009
    Amazing final chapter to an amazing story! Loved every bit of it. If you would do a Mpreg sequel, that would be awesome but no pressure! :D
    Great job!!
    Report Review

  • From ANON - Lizzie on November 24, 2009
    Wow, I can't believe this is over :(, I'm gonna miss it so much! One of the best fanfics I have found in a long time! I don't review anything very often, but I feel this fic deserves it, because a lot of time and effort has clearly gone into it, as proven by the Author's notes at the end. I hope you do make a sequel, I will be looking forward to it enthusiastically if you do!

    I've had this fic bookmarked since about chapter 6, and so far you've been the most consistent author (in quality aswell!) I've come across since I first stumbled across fanfiction! Thank you for this story, I'm going to keep it bookmarked so I can go back and read it again and again! :)

    Lizzie
    Report Review

T.O.S. | Content Guidelines | DMCA Info | F.A.Q. | Facebook | Tumblr | Abuse | Support | Contact | Donate

Click Here!